Google
 

Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 24th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2018 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at aardvark.co.uk



Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Why are state employees above the law?

27 September 2018

I've written before about the dubious distinction between "unlawful" and "illegal" in this country.

It seems that if we (the great unwashed) break the laws of the land, we are deemed to be acting illegally and, if caught, prosecuted and convicted, suffer penalties which may vary from a fine through to a lengthy term of imprisonment.

Laws without penalties attached for their breach are useless laws.

How many people would we find speeding on our roads if there was no fine or other censure for exceeding the posted limits for example?

So the courts are empowered to punish those who show contempt for the laws of the land, and that is how it should be.

However, if you break the laws of the land whilst in the employ of the state, no such regime of penalty applies.

The reality is that if a state-employee breaks the law whilst performing their duties, their actions are not deemed to be "illegal" at all, merely "unlawful".

Now this has to be the single largest injustice in this country.

We've seen countless instances where the rights and freedoms of NZ citizens and residents have been trampled by state employees in ways that utterly breach the clearly written laws of the land -- yet nobody is held accountable to the extent that they are fined or imprisoned. Indeed, they don't even lose their jobs!

Scores of NZers were spied on by the GCSB in clear breach of the law -- nobody was punished for that *crime*.

Kim Dotcom's house was raided by armed forces, he and his family was held at gunpoint and most of his assets were carted off by state servants in an action that the courts ruled to be against the law -- but once again, none of those who made the conscious decision to break the laws put in place to protect the public, were punished for their contempt.

Scores of NZers were stopped, searched and detained by armed police in rural NZ on the premise that there were "terrorists" afoot. Yet again, an action that was in breach of the law and nobody was fined or imprisoned for their breaking of the law.

And now it's happening again!

According to this RadioNZ story, MSD has been caught "unlawfully" using fake names on legal documents.

If you or I were to forge a name on a court document, I suspect we'd get a pretty significant punishment for doing so -- but despite having been previously warned that this practice was against the law, MSD staff ignored that warning and continued the practice.

By engaging in this practice, MSD had "breached Ms L's right to natural justice" and also "there was no legal authority for the [MSD] committee to issue decision using fictitious names".

The judge ruled that the ministry "did not act lawfully when it took the extraordinary step of having members of the committee issue their decisions using fictitious names and signatures".

Okay, so people have (very clearly) broken the law -- what's going to happen to them?

Answer: absolutely bloody nothing!

Is it any wonder therefore, that we continue to see state employees flouting the very laws that have been put in place by parliament to (supposedly) protect the citizens of the country from abuse?

Surely this is just as much of a joke as removing the penalties for speeding, rape and murder would be.

Why do we sit around and accept this double-standard?

What the hell is wrong with people?

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say in the Aardvark Forums.

PERMALINK to this column


Rank This Aardvark Page

 

Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines

 


Features:

Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam

 

Recent Columns

Features over robustness?
I do a lot of video editing... I have to in order to keep my two YouTube channels chugging along...

It's that time again!
It's less than six weeks to Christmas...

Seriously, who designed this?
The hot news on the wires this morning is the unexpected and unauthorised temporary routing of Google traffic via China...

NatRad gives up on real news
As I'm sure all regular readers of this column are aware, I am not particularly impressed with the objectivity or performance of today's mainstream media...

Tech giants consolidate their power
Two of the biggest names on the Internet are Amazon and Apple...

Thanks for borrowing our software
An unknown (but seemingly quite large) number of Windows 10 Pro users have had problems over the past 24 hours...

Meccano jumps the shark?
Who remembers the days of Meccano?...

Cores vs clock speed
There's a very real battle going on between Intel and AMD...

It cost how much?
Yesterday I bought a new disk drive...

In 10 years the world will change forever
Nuclear fusion is still just 10 years away...

The strangest thing
I've written a few columns on helium before, because it's a damned interesting element and it is becoming increasingly precious...