Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 25th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2019 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

EU to ban user-generated content sites?

29 October 2018

Some of the internet's most popular websites are driven by user-generated content.

There's YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and a raft of other entities which rely on users uploading material which, in turn, attracts other users which, in turn, exposes them to advertising.

Although sometimes the ads are pretty annoying, this add-funded, user-generated content paradigm has worked pretty well for quite some time now.

Of course there are some issues -- such as when users upload someone else's copyrighted material without permission. To reduce this, both YouTube and Facebook have automated content-ID systems which attempt to identify and delete infringing material. So far, most copyright owners have accepted that this is a "best efforts" approach on the part of the Net companies and so we only occasionally see law-suits claiming losses.

However, the EU is a bit challenged in this regard.

The bureaucrats in Brussels seem hell-bent on passing new laws that would effectively hold companies like YouTube and Facebook responsible and legally liable for any copyright infringements created by users' uploads.

If this law were to pass (and it's looking like it might), it could spell the death of many very popular net-based services in the EU.

After having suffered a beating at the hands of the adpocalypse, where advertisers left in droves after finding their promotions running on "unsuitable" content uploaded by users, YouTube is running very gun-shy and appears unwilling to take the risk that they might face huge fines if people upload movies, music or other material without the permission of the copyright owner.

It seems that the EU's legislators have a motto of "we're not happy until you're not happy" when it comes to regulations and this latest attempt at scuttling freedoms would effectively turn the internet into a place where all you could find was material produced by corporate entities.

Although this "Copyright Directive" was originally rejected by the EU parliament back in July, it has been revised and the new version recently passed the first hurdle to becoming law. A final vote is to be held in January.

The Verge did a piece on this issue which explains the ins and outs but most critically, it would impose a "link tax" on hyperlinks to copyrighted material and make publishers liable for any and all copyright infringements created by uploaders to that site.

YouTube has officially officially warned that this directive would place the entire creative online community at risk and has warned that if enacted, YouTube might have to block all EU countries from accessing its platform.

And now, YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki has urged video makers using the platform to "take action immediately" to protest the proposed legislation.

"This legislation poses a threat to both your livelihood and your ability to share your voice with the world", she stated in this blog post.

So what the hell is going on in Europe?

Did Britain do the right thing and decide to pull out of the EU, given the latter's propensity to engage in all sorts of mind-numbing and freedom-wrecking regulation?

Are the EU legislators effectively building their own cyber-equivalent of the Berlin Wall by creating an online regulatory environment which is so hostile that no sensible operators will allow access to their content from this part of the world?

I'd love to get readers' take on this.

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say in the Aardvark Forums.

PERMALINK to this column

Rank This Aardvark Page


Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines



Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam


Recent Columns

There is no centre to the universe
In the beginning there was nothing. No matter, no time, no universe...

When less is more?
It used to be that being an electronics hobbyist was easy...

Why time flies
As older folk like myself are very much aware, time seems to pass more quickly as you age...

Oh the irony
YouTube has made a lot of noise about enforcing its community standards of late...

The end of live streaming?
The events of last Friday continue to have deep repercussions on the shape and form that the internet may take from this point forwards...

More internet restrictions
It really does look as if the internet is dying -- from the perspective of being an open, free and somewhat anonymous method of accessing and disseminating information...

The future looks bleak
Today's column was going to be about the tragedy of the Christchurch mosque attacks which happened on Friday of last week...

No longer plane simple
Just about every country in the developed world has now grounded the Boeing 737 Max 8 aircraft, after two crashes that have resulted in the deaths of hundreds of people...

When the sun shines
We all know where clouds live... in the sky...

Actions speak louder than words
I've written a few columns about the (apparent) decline in geekiness and the sad way people seem to be uninterested in the technology that powers the world around us...

A black-box society?
A few days ago I made a video (as you do) about how there seems to be a lack of interest in "making stuff" these days...