Google
 

Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 24th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2019 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at aardvark.co.uk



Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Google really is being evil

25 May 2018

Google has often been slammed for not adequately enforcing or protecting the copyrights of content creators.

Recording artists are still bitching that the company's YouTube division does not do enough to police and enforce the copyright which protects their work. For its part, Google claims it does everything possible to ensure that copyrights are respected. To this end it will take down videos that are reported as infringing copyright and it has an automated "Content ID" system which pattern matches for protected works.

Over the years, Google has managed to convince authorities that it is a good actor in the world of copyright. Even though Youtube plays host to countless infringing works, the company itself is not held accountable for those infringements because its "policies" are designed to do whatever it can to prevent those infringements.

This seems a little at-odds with the way that other companies, who also operate on a "best efforts" basis, have been hung, drawn and quartered by the courts for doing exactly the same thing.

Well I think Google's claims that it does all it can to prevent copyright infringement have just been shown to be dead wrong.

I refer to the fact that film-maker Philip Bloom has come out accusing Google itself of stealing his copyrighted videos.

This isn't simply a case of someone uploading the guy's work to YouTube and Google failing to take action when informed... it's a blatant case of Google using his work without license and without payment.

In this case, the company seems to have decided to operate on the principle that "it's only a crime if we get caught" and figured that nobody would ever find out that Mr Bloom's intellectual property had been "stolen" because its use was for an internal video presentation.

Sorry Google... not good enough!!

Many an otherwise fantastic YouTube channel has been wiped from the face of the interwebs by Google's over-enthusiastic copyright enforcement policies -- yet when they get caught doing it themselves it's a big "so what?".

According to the BBC report, even though they have been caught out stealing this guy's stuff, they have yet to make an offer to compensate him for what they used.

It's now becoming very clear as to why, just this month, Google struck out its founding mantra "don't be evil" from its corporate code of conduct. What's more, now that it's gone, they clearly have every intention of being as evil as is necessary to line shareholders' pockets to the maximum extent.

How tragic it is that a company, founded on such wonderful principles, is now demonstrating all that is bad about multinational corporate culture.

Of course this isn't the first instance of a supposedly "anti-piracy" group being hoist by its own petard. Let's not forget this story from 2011 in which the work of a dutch artist was used without permission as part of the anti-piracy warnings on DVDs.

Yes, it seems that copyright law is seen as only applying to "other people" who don't have enough lawyers or cash to protect themselves from its provisions.

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say in the Aardvark Forums.

PERMALINK to this column


Rank This Aardvark Page

 

Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines

 


Features:

Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam

 

Recent Columns

Drying up the talent pool
I hate to mention drones in the first column of the week but I'm afraid it has to be done...

GPS version of Y2K in just six weeks
Hands up everyone who remembers all the fuss and fear that surrounded the predictions of disaster at the end of last century?...

A lost Opportunity
Why does the word "Opportunity" in the title of today's column have a capital letter?...

Quick, call the police!
Here's some silliness I thought I'd never see...

A foreboding observation?
Summer, it's a great time of year...

Any excuse to play the victim?
There was a time when human beings were tough and resilient...

The sweet taste of failure
I used to eat a lot of chocolate... loved the stuff...

Greed cometh before...
As I wind down from a heady day at The Treaty grounds yesterday (cue Tui's ad) I find myself wondering what the hell TradeMe is doing?...

Google me this
I think sometimes people forget that Google is not a philanthropic organisation...

Where are all the kids?
In a rather unusual occurrence, several aircraft turned up at the airfield on Sunday...

Regulation for safety or control?
I've just returned from my regular trip to the PO Box with a bag of goodies...